Re: Pricing, labelling -Reply -Reply

Jan Derks (
Thu, 9 Dec 1999 14:16:15 -0800 (PST)

Leslie - I suppose there are always exceptions...We got burned when we
purchased "The Pillow Book" with NO rating shown in VIDEOHOUND or on the
video case. We purchased additional copies later and discovered that
the video had a NC-17 rating on both the case and in the new edition of
V.HOUND. It does happen occasionally.
Jan Derks
A/V Collections Librarian
Arapahoe Library District, Littleton, CO

Leslie Andersen wrote:

> Why wouldn't the MPAA rating be on a video? Do you
> remove the boxes when you process them? I would
> assume that if a rating is not found then there isn't one for
> that particular title. Remember, the system is
> VOLUNTARY. No one HAS to put a rating on their title.
> Most feature films are rated simply because movie theaters
> won't show a film unless it has a rating. Its not because
> producers and distributors have an altruistic streak;
> remember Hollywood is a business, nothing more.
> Also, if the rating isn't there then what is the concern? It
> simply means that that title has not been rated (sometimes
> identified by *NR*). I'm assuming you're not imposing a
> rating yourself when there isn't one? I have not found a
> case where a title has a rating and it is not found on the box.
> Yes, it might be small but it is found there somewhere.
> Again, by placing an additional label on the case you are
> endorsing this private rating system (again IMHO). Parents
> who are concerned may either ask for more information or
> view it themselves before their children do. It is not our job
> to *advertise* this rating system. We don't *advertise*
> books by rating them, why video?
> +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
> Leslie Andersen
> Non-Print Materials Evaluator
> County of Los Angeles Public Library