Whenever these things get discussed, its always the extremes that
emerge as examples. This makes the discussion more difficult to
understand for some. Its the gray area of day-to-day operations that
most people need help with.
To get back to the original example of Chinese Ghost Story...no US
rights...production company out of business...I am sure there is a
rights owner, but they are in Hong Kong. All of this would likely
factor to exclude it from the "...available at a reasonable cost"
This seems very different to me than a Kino title, etc. I would NEVER
advocate or permit a public showing without proper arrangements. In
truth, I am viewed on campus as an administrative wonk because I am the
one who tells faculty they have to pay for rights for coursepacks, pay
Swank or New Yorker or Kino for PPR, etc. We are talking about
exceptions, extraordinary circumstances.
Please don't confuse a reasoned argument for fair use with blatant
disregard for the law. You can't put those examples under the same
>>> Herownword@aol.com 6/2/2006 10:37 AM >>>
I've been out of town (in beautiful San Francisco!) for a week and just
some of the posts on locating copyright holders. I would like to add
perspective of a small independent producer. Her Own Words has had
telephone number, email address, physical address, and post office
address since 1993 (and most of those addresses since it was founded in
Nevertheless, every few months we get a phone call from someone
librarian) wanting to see if Her Own Words still exists. "But [insert
of large national distributor/jobber here] said that you didn't exist
and there was no way to track you down or find any of your films" is
inevitable next statement. Blessings on the librarians who take the
call and verify the (mis)information.
VIDEOLIB is intended to encourage the broad and lively discussion of issues relating to the selection, evaluation, acquisition,bibliographic control, preservation, and use of current and evolving video formats in libraries and related institutions. It is hoped that the list will serve as an effective working tool for video librarians, as well as a channel of communication between libraries,educational institutions, and video producers and distributors.