The issue is not so much the "machine" as the approach you take to get your
content onto DVD. If you are going to be "authoring" (i.e., adding menus,
defining chapter stops, etc.) the lab or editor will be capturing the video
and audio "streams" separately into the authoring program to be used, and
in that process the captioning gets dropped out, resulting in the need to
re-caption using the .scc files that John mentioned.
If, instead, all you need is a straight copy of the entire program, as is,
to DVD, this can be done via a much simpler and MUCH less expensive
process. As mentioned, some labs aren't aware of this and others, frankly,
aren't interested in providing this lower cost service.
At 07:05 PM 1/12/2006 -0500, you wrote:
>My experience has been that the fancier the encoding machine, the more
>difficulty they have with closed captions.
>There are plenty of VHS duplicators for whom going from BetaSP to DVD-R
>(at least) with closed captions presents no problems at all. The
>captions shoot straight across.
>Once you start talking about .scc files, then you do run into large
>All the best,
> John Hoskyns-Abrahall
>PO Box 149
>Oley, PA 19547
>[mailto:email@example.com] On Behalf Of Susan Weber
>Sent: Wednesday, January 11, 2006 12:41 PM
>Subject: [Videolib] Closed Captions
>On the subject of closed captioning, I've just run into a lab problem. I
>wonder if anybody else knows the solution.
>The program was produced in analog and the master is in Betacam SP.
>There is closed captioning and the VHS copy has it.
>We want a DVD sub-master, with the closed captions.
>The lab says they cannot embed the closed captioning without incurring a
>very high cost. Can anyone help?
>Hix Susan wrote:
> > Hi everyone,
> > I'm helping to coordinate an effort to provide closed captioned media
> > to deaf and hard of hearing students here at Santa Rosa Junior
> > We have been producing captioned videos with permission when we are
> > unable to find them for sale with captioning.
> > I'm looking for the copyright holders for three titles:
> > 1. Robert Arneson, copyright 1983, 17 mins, purchased 1987 from The
> > Drawing Society, 415 7^th Ave., #66, New York, NY 10001
> > 2. Masters of Illusion, cr 1991, 30 mins, purchased 1994 from the
> > National Gallery of Art, Publication Mail Orders, 2000 S. Club
> > Drive, Landover, MD 20785, (301) 322-5900
> > 3. Piet Mondriaan: A Film Essay, 1980, 18 mins, purchased prior to
> > 1988
> > Thanks in advance for any help you can offer!
> > /*/~Susan~/*/
> > Susan Hix
> > Closed Caption Coordinator
> > Media Services
> > Santa Rosa Junior College
> > firstname.lastname@example.org <mailto:email@example.com>
> > phone: (707) 521-7927
> > fax: (707) 535-3733
>Susan Weber, Media Librarian
>Langara College, Advanced Education Media
> Acquisitions Centre
>100 West 49th Avenue, Vancouver, B.C. V5Y 2Z6
>Tel. 604-323-5533 email: firstname.lastname@example.org
>Fast Forward Media Showcase, May 2-3, 2006
>Videolib mailing list
>Videolib mailing list
Ben Achtenberg / Fanlight Productions
4196 Washington Street, Boston, MA 02131
(617) 469-4999 Fax: (617) 469-3379
VISIT OUR WEBSITE: www.fanlight.com
Videolib mailing list