Didn't mean to open up this age-old can of worms on everyone again... I
fully realize that this will concern many legal issues and would require
licensing in some form or another. My question pertained to the
procedures libraries may be using (taking into account, and not trying
to circumnavigate licensing concerns).
The licensing concerns will be a point of education for some others
outside the realm of my department, however (and I feel fairly
well-armed to tackle that given the informative discussions that have
taken place on this list in the past). I definitely agree with Jessica
on the rights issues catching up with the technology. This causes some
pretty severe disconnents for people who do not understand the content /
legal side of things. Recently, we had a situation where some
non-library professionals walked through our stacks area and were amazed
that we still had a physical collection of vhs's and dvd's ("Don't they
just put all that on servers now??"). I felt like handing them a Disney
film and telling him to see if he could get the licensing clearance
sometime in his lifetime...
Meghann R. Matwichuk, M.S.
Instructional Media Department
Morris Library, University of Delaware
181 S. College Ave.
Newark, DE 19717
Jessica Rosner wrote:
>As I have mentioned before digitizing feature stuff is going to present the
>same issues as trying to get PPR rights in fact more. I doubt some of our
>contracts even cover this so for instance if you wanted permission to
>digitize l'AGE D'OR you would have to deal with someone in France and GOOD
>LUCK. The technology may be there but I don't think the rights issues will
>ever catch up.
>>Thanks for alerting us to this, Meghann
>>Looks to me as if, in terms of content, CDigix is pretty much offering on
>>demand entertainment programming rather than stuff that would be of use in
>>dorms. The company has license arrangements with entertainment outlets and
>>they provide this stuff on demand.
>>I can see how, legally, the kind of digitization of copyrighted content you
>>describe below could possibly work. Scrub or not, digitization of whole
>>copyrighted works for on demand delivery simply ain't covered by either
>>Title 117 or TEACH.
>>Do you have more info?
>>At 09:58 AM 8/22/2005 -0400, you wrote:
>>>Hello Patti (et. al.),
>>>Thanks for raising this topic on Video-lib -- I have just been charged
>>>with investigating this topic as well! Please, group, reply to the list
>>>The digital content service that I have been asked to find out more about
>>>is called CDigix http://www.cdigix.com/website/cdigix/ -- does anyone have
>>>any specific knowledge about this product? One library we've talked with
>>>described the procedure they use when working with this provider as follows:
>>>1. Requests for providing media content online via CDigix go through IT.
>>>IT coordinates the service with CDigix, including troubleshooting and
>>>2. Faculty complete form on IT page and check box related to educational
>>>use of the media. Library is not involved in researching or obtaining
>>>copyright permissions to reformat or digitize media in Library collection.
>>>The transaction is between the faculty member and CDigix.
>>>3. Library receives request for physical copy (VHS or DVD) from IT. Copy
>>>must be a legal copy in Library collection.
>>>4. Media is sent to IT for digitization.
>>>5. At semester end, digital media files are scrubbed by IT.
>>>6. Library continues to research, collect, catalog, house, and maintain
>>>video for instructional use by faculty and students.
>>>Does this sound like the typical procedure used by other institutions /
>>>academic libraries using streaming and course management systems?
>>>Thanks in advance for any input,
>>>Meghann R. Matwichuk, M.S.
>>>Instructional Media Department
>>>Morris Library, University of Delaware
>>>181 S. College Ave.
>>>Newark, DE 19717
>>>Patricia McVay-Gorrell wrote:
>>>>Our campus is investigating course management systems and the question
>>>>that I'm presented with is "What steps need to be taken to stream
>>>>educational and theatrical films to the 'chosen' system for specific
>>>>class assignments?" The IT folks plan to have a dedicated server and they
>>>>assured us that class assignments will be password protected.
>>>>At this point, some of my questions are: would they be using clips vs.
>>>>entire films; the issue of changing formats within copyright; how secure
>>>>is the server and the course management system; are there 'guest'
>>>>privileges for non-registered students; are the students permitted to
>>>>download the film; server space issues--at least half of our course
>>>>reserves are theatrical releases; how secure are the passwords and the
>>>>people entrusted with them (smile); the estimated cost to the Libraries
>>>>for each title; estimated turnaround time for the vendor's permission
>>>>once a faculty member decides what films to use; turnaround time for
>>>>changing the format; increase in our staff time, etc.
>>>>Has anyone offered this service to their faculty yet? Or studied the
>>>>issue and would you be willing to share your results? Please reply
>>>>directly to <firstname.lastname@example.org> unless others express an interest.
>>>>Many thanks on this gorgeous Saturday morning in Ohio!
>>>>Patricia McVay Gorrell
>>>>Media Library Manager
>>>>Instructional Media Center
>>>>The College of Wooster
>>>>1140 Beall Avenue
>>>>Wooster, OH 44691-2364
>>>>Videolib mailing list
>>>Videolib mailing list
>>Media Resources Center
>>"Movies are poems, a holy bible, the great mother of us."
>> --Ted Berrigan
>>Videolib mailing list
>Proud Resident of a BLUE STATE
>333 W 39th St. 503
>NY NY 10018
>Videolib mailing list
Videolib mailing list