


Copyright 1995 ABC-CLIO. This review was taken from the ABC-CLIO Video Rating Guide for Libraries on CD-ROM, a 5-year compilation of over 8900 video titles and reviews, 1990-1994. For information regarding order VRGL CD-ROM, contact: ABC-CLIO, P.O. Box 1911, Santa Barbara, CA 93116-1911; 805-968-1911
This following text has been included in the UCB Media Resources Center Web site with the kind permission of the publishers.

This particular program focuses not so much on the ecological
disaster in the Amazon basin, which has attracted so much world
attention, but rather on the often violent conflict between
Brazil's landless poor, who number in the millions, and the
wealthy landowners who have displaced them. The central theme of
Killing for Land is that the rural poor are being pushed further
and further into the rain forest in search of land to cultivate -
because Brazil's economic policy promotes and subsidizes cattle
farming and other kinds of agribusiness at their expense. Those
who attempt to eke out an existence on these often abandoned or
unused ranch and farm lands are subjected to an endless cycle of
violence and harassment by gunmen in the hire of absentee
landowners, who reap the benefits of government subsidies. The
program asserts that the Brazilian government has been unwilling
or unable to protect the squatters and their supporters from this
violence. In turn, the desperate squatters flee further into the
forest, and contribute to its devastation.
Killing for Land illustrates how the human and ecological
tragedy of the Amazon has become a factor in the Brazilian state
of Rondonia. There, cameras follow the efforts of squatters to
remain on a largely deserted 12,000-acre cattle ranch, while
fending off the hired gunmen. Interviews with the settlers reveal
both their determination and their desperation, as their leaders
and those who wish to help them are harassed or murdered, perhaps
with the connivance of the local authorities. In addition to this
closeup tracking of events, Killing for Land covers the 1989
Brazilian presidential election, in which land reform was a
central issue, and in which the pro-reform candidate was defeated
by a narrow five percent margin.
This is a very well-made documentary with a strong point of
view about the social and political conflicts in Brazil that have
helped to fuel the fires that are now consuming the Amazon rain
forest. It argues implicitly that the problem of how to save the
rain forest is an economic and political as well as an ecological
one, and that until solutions are reached, the forests will
continue to burn.
In the early 1980s the Brazilian government established a
frontier town deep in the forest, called Rondonia. A dirt road
was cut through the jungle to provide access. Then the land
surrounding Rondonia was divided into thousands of 100-acre
parcels to be given to landless peasants to be farmed. This
documentary provides a ten-year longitudinal study of this
project and its results. Irreparable damage to the rain forest,
decimation of the indigenous Indian population, and widespread
farming and ranching failures are a few of the topics discussed.
Cowell explains the underlying problems of the region by
presenting case studies of individual homesteaders and of the
local Indian tribe as they encounter repeated problems in the
jungle.
Despite the bad publicity and overwhelming failure of the
homesteading project, the World Bank stepped in to loan money to
pave the road to Rondonia, which resulted in the problems
spreading more rapidly. At the close of this program, the viewer
is told that a new political climate appears to be emerging in
Brazil. The newly elected president is heeding the warnings of
the environmentalists and establishing an area protected from
development.
The production values are consistently high, with
often-spectacular footage illustrating most aspects of the
narration. The production style is lucid, with an easy-to-follow
structure that gracefully interlaces dozens of elements into a
striking portrayal of a desperate community. Packed with
information, this documentary sheds new light on the issue of the
destruction of the rain forest.
Highly recommended, this is an outstanding choice either as a
first selection or as an additional selection in this subject
area.
The presentation traces the development and later cessation of
the Brazilian government's mining projects in the Carajas
Mountains - not only for gold but also for bauxite, chrome, zinc,
copper, and iron ore. The government, seeking ways to pay off its
enormous national debt, believed it had found a solution in the
vast mineral and ore deposits of Amazonia. But what looked like
an ideal solution in 1980 escalated into an enormous
environmental problem by 1990.
The statistics quoted are staggering (for example, 1,800 tons
of poisonous mercury were dumped into the Amazon in the 1980s),
and the documentary also reveals the negative consequences to the
environment that "progress" has wrought. Eventually the whole
mining operation was abandoned as a result of worldwide concern
and creditor ultimatums, which ordered the government to clean up
the Carajas in order to get any more loans.
Technically, this production is very well done. The visuals
and narration work together to provide a wealth of information.
The camerawork is particularly pleasing, offering a wide variety
of panoramic shots of the destruction of the land and closeups of
local illegal miners.
Recommended for public and school libraries, the video
addresses issues that are topical and of concern to everyone who
inhabits the planet Earth.
Fortunately, this program stands very well on its own. Viewers
will not feel they are missing anything that may have come up in
the preceding segments of the series. Encompassing Mendes' life,
activities to save the rainforest, and death, the video
telescopes many of the issues facing Amazonia: the global
implications of deforestation, displacement of the region's
indigenous peoples, greedy ranchers murdering Indians or anyone
standing in the way of expanded profits for themselves, a
government itching to boost the nation into the ranks of the
developed nations of the world, and finally, Brazil's initial
steps being taken to preserve Earth's biggest "oxygen plant" -
Amazonia.
By itself, The Killing of Chico Mendes serves as a competent
overview of the social and political issues surrounding the
saving of the rain forest. As it does not cover the variety of
unique plant and animal life that was being lost to
deforestation, an excellent supplement to this video is one that
many public libraries already have acquired through the MacArthur
Video Library, Amazonia: A Celebration of Life (Leapin' Lemur
Productions, 1984). These two videos together cover the
ecological, social, and political issues of this eminently
important topic. As The Killing of Chico Mendes is very
competently produced and edited, well-written and professionally
photographed, it is recommended for libraries having the
MacArthur Video Library title and even for those that do not. It
is well worth the price for public and all high school and
college library video collections.
Decade of Destruction: Killing for Land
Decade of Destruction:
In the Ashes of the Forest, Part 1
In the Ashes of the Forest, Part 2Decade of Destruction: Mountains of Gold
Decade of Destruction: The Killing of Chico Mendes

Go to Media Resources Center Entry Page