


Copyright 1995 ABC-CLIO. This review was taken from the ABC-CLIO Video Rating Guide for Libraries on CD-ROM, a 5-year compilation of over 8900 video titles and reviews, 1990-1994. For information regarding order VRGL CD-ROM, contact: ABC-CLIO, P.O. Box 1911, Santa Barbara, CA 93116-1911; 805-968-1911
This following text has been included in the UCB Media Resources Center Web site with the kind permission of the publishers.

A superb production, it is well narrated by Will Lyman and
Mauricio Obregon, as well as various university professors and
historians drawing on the explorer's own letters and ship's logs.
The dramatization and photography are first-rate, documenting the
European and Asian world as it was known prior to and at the time
of Columbus.
Live action takes the viewer to the Spice Islands, Japan,
China, Cairo, Constantinople, Genoa, and Venice, while explaining
the lure of the Orient for the Italian merchants and Columbus in
particular. Artwork of the time in the form of oil paintings and
illuminations are interspersed throughout, thus enhancing the
presentation.
The introductory segment sets the stage for the seven-hour
series and poses the questions that following episodes attempt to
answer. Among them: Who was this man? What happened when he
brought two worlds together for the first time? The story spans
the globe and retraces the extraordinary voyages of the explorer
from the Old World to the New.
This video is highly recommended and will be an excellent
purchase for junior high, high school, college, and public
libraries.
An Idea Takes Shape focuses on Columbus' efforts to gain
financing for his proposals to sail to the west in search of
Cathay. The documentary travels to Portugal first, where Columbus
received his basic introduction to navigation and grew up in the
time of Prince Henry, the greatest sailor of his time. Tales of
the riches of the Orient came back to Portugal, which was the
preeminent exploring nation, and Columbus could not help but be
possessed by the idea of finding a shorter route. His travels
along the West African coast showed him the value of gold, while
his adventures in the northern seas gave him tantalizing hints of
a vast country lying to the west. Skulls of people who were
supposed to inhabit these lands were found in the Scandinavian
countries and Columbus believed them to be the remains of
Orientals because of their flat foreheads.
Columbus' knowledge of the shape of the earth was never in
question, and, indeed, no intelligent person believed that the
world was flat. What he failed to accept was the size of the
planet, even though ancient Greeks had charted almost exactly the
number of degrees that comprised the circumference of the earth.
Columbus shortened the distance between degrees, thus shrinking
the planet by almost 25 percent and in the process stretching the
Asian continent almost to where the Bahamas are. Clearly, he
adapted "facts" to fit his theories, and science be damned.
The documentary ends with his tribulations and successes in
Spain, where Ferdinand and Isabella were engaged in ridding their
country of the Moors and had little time for the Genoese sailor
with grandiose ideas. When their "Reconquista" campaign finally
did succeed, they were able to give him another chance to explain
his proposals, but he made such impossible demands that they
dismissed him again. Queen Isabella, however, extended Columbus
one last chance to make his case and tone down some of his
requirements.
This is a beautifully filmed, exquisitely documented series
that belongs in every general collection. Long after the last
"Columbus Landed Here" T-shirt is sold, this series will serve as
a legacy to the vain, flawed, devious man who changed the course
of history with his dreams, creativity, daring, and genius.
Columbus's World
An Idea Takes Shape

Go to Media Resources Center Entry Page